We interviewed 12 in-house marketers about how they're handling AI search. At the end of each conversation, we asked for honest feedback: what have you liked about working with agencies, what haven't you liked, and what would you want from one right now?
The backdrop matters. When we asked where their AI search budget had gone, almost nobody said agencies. Four put the money into tools, four into in-house people and three into a lean team with a few tools. Three had recently cut or replaced an agency. Will Heany's team at Snowflake moved "almost entirely away from agencies to in-house" about a year ago. Eden Wallace at NRG let go of a long-time agency for most of her seven websites.
Nobody was bitter about it. Most had good things to say about agencies they'd worked with. Will spent six years on the agency side himself. But their answers were remarkably consistent about what an agency has to offer now to earn a seat at the table.
1. Bring what we can't see from the inside
The most common reason in-house teams still want an agency is perspective. An in-house team sees one company. An agency sees dozens.
Alexandre Teulade at ClearPoint Strategy wants "almost a partner that is able to tell you you are going in the wrong direction," because "we are one company, we know our business, but you guys are working with hundreds of those and you have more insights." Eden values the same thing: an agency can share "what they're doing with other people," while her own team only has its own experience.
Jonathan Rundle at ChemPoint, a former agency marketer, described the ideal relationship as "a force multiplier." The agency brings a playbook it has seen work elsewhere, ideally "something that we haven't thought of ourselves or we've been unable to execute on ourselves."
2. Don't hand us a template
The flip side of cross-client experience is the template, and in-house marketers can spot one immediately.
Anton Holm at the International Rescue Committee says agencies often show up with "the SEO playbook that works for people running Shopify accounts." A humanitarian nonprofit raising emergency funds and advocating on policy has different goals, and the agency needs to start there. Lance Holt at Morning Brew sees the same risk inside his own company of 10 to 12 brands: "That mindset of wanting to templatize things across the board has to change," because audiences "behave differently, they engage differently."
Will made the same point about technical products. A complex product like Snowflake's "requires that higher level of detail and just knowledge about a space for things to make sense."
3. Quality over volume
Alexandre's team parted ways with agencies that "were pushing a lot of content, a lot of blogs." That doesn't work anymore. When anyone can generate commodity content with AI, what's worth paying for is "non-commodity content and specific insights" built with someone who understands the domain.
4. Treat the in-house team like experts
Jordin Frey at U.S. Career Institute wants an agency that "understands that we do have someone in-house that does know what they're talking about." Too often, she says, agencies "assume no one knows what they're talking about and kind of steamroll the conversation." The best partners can take pushback when she knows a metric doesn't matter for her industry.
Anton put it in practical terms: sync on what the in-house team already does before deciding what the agency adds. Otherwise you end up with "overlapping priorities and agendas."
5. Move fast, and work around our blockers
Irina Jordan at Checkmate prefers smaller, nimble agencies, or even specialized freelancers, because "I want agility, speed and expertise." Her test for any agency is simple: how quick is the turnaround, and how quickly do they provide updates?
Eden described a frustration every enterprise marketer will recognize. At one point, getting a single page changed took an average of 58 days because of how siloed her organization was. Her agency kept bringing new pages to build, and she kept explaining they were stuck. What she wanted was an agency that would "think outside of the box": if pages can't ship, shift to content, reporting or technical work that can. "I shouldn't be the one bringing that to the table if I'm paying the agency."
6. Give us real data, tied to real results
Stefanie Maio at Evans Hotels wants raw data she can load into BigQuery and explore herself. Sometimes, she said, agencies share data framed "so that the agency looks fabulous." She'd rather know when something isn't working: "It's okay if a campaign isn't doing great. Maybe that's not the campaign for us."
Jonathan wants the same honesty applied to ROI. A realistic projection tied to leads and the bottom line, not sessions, would make it much easier to take an agency pitch to finance.
7. Fill the gaps in-house teams can't
James Shaw at The Alliance named the clearest opening. Most in-house teams are good at research and on-site SEO. Distribution is harder. "The new era is going to be about third-party mentions and referrals from alternative platforms." Digital PR is where he thinks agencies can play "a really big role."
What we're taking from this
Almost everything these marketers asked for comes back to one idea: an agency has to own the outcome, not just the deliverables. A scope of work tells us what we're responsible for delivering. It doesn't tell us whether the work made a difference.
That's the standard we've built 97th Floor around. As Sam, our VP of Client Services, puts it, our responsibility "isn't to blindly accept a goal and hope we can achieve it. It's to use our expertise to determine what's realistic, where the biggest opportunities exist, and what it will actually take to get there."
Here's how that lines up with what we heard:
- Start with your business, not our playbook. Before we recommend anything, we learn your audience, your goals and what your team already owns. Then we recommend where your investment will make the biggest difference, even if that means challenging the original plan.
- Bring the perspective you can't get from the inside. We work across dozens of industries and run our own experiments, from new content formats to what earns AI citations. When we learn something, you hear about it, including when it means telling you you're heading in the wrong direction.
- Work as an extension of your team. Your people know the business. We bring pattern recognition from across clients. The best work happens when both sides can push back on each other.
- Choose original insight over volume. AI made commodity content cheap. What still earns rankings and citations is content built on real expertise and a real understanding of the audience, so that's where we put our effort.
- Work around blockers instead of waiting them out. If dev queues or approvals stall one workstream, we don't point to the scope of work and wait. We move effort to work that can ship, and we flag it before you have to ask.
- Report honestly, tied to revenue. We share what's working, what isn't, why, and what we're changing. And we measure success in leads, pipeline and revenue, not just sessions.
- Fill the gaps in-house teams can't. Especially off-site work like digital PR and third-party mentions, which shapes so much of AI visibility.
An agency is a partner, or it's a line item
The in-house marketers we talked to don't need an agency to do the work for them. Most of them are already doing it. They need a partner who brings something they can't get on their own: perspective from across the industry, honest data, the ability to move fast, and real ownership of the results.
An agency that can't offer that is just a line item, and line items get cut.
Looking for a partner, not a vendor? See how we approach GEO/AEO, SEO and content, or let's talk.