Also available on:
The New Reality of Search
SEO is facing its biggest change in 15 years. With AI summaries and LLMs taking over parts of search, traditional metrics need a complete rethink. The surprise? Flat or declining traffic numbers may signal success in 2025.
"If it's not expensive, time-consuming, or taking resources, it won't provide value for SEO," says consultant Nick LeRoy. While traffic drops from AI and LLMs taking market share, revenue often stays stable or grows. "It's hard to pay electric bills with sessions."
Take HubSpot - their blog traffic fell from 10 to 2 million monthly visits. Yet this doesn't spell failure. Instead, it shows better targeting and engagement with their core audience. Companies succeeding in 2025 focus on quality traffic that converts, not just high numbers.
The Death of AI-Generated Content Farms
The era of mass AI-generated content is ending. While some brands still succeed with volume, engagement metrics increasingly determine rankings. Companies need to invest in fewer, better pages that truly serve their audience.
Some brands still create content like "motivational quotes for Tuesday" followed by "uplifting quotes for Thursday" with CTAs for complex B2B software. This approach brings traffic but few results. The winners in 2025's search environment focus on content that connects directly to their products and services.
Message-First: The New Strategy
Smart companies now start with messages, not channels. They understand their audience's needs first, then create content that works across their entire marketing mix. This approach means:
- Understanding audience problems before creating solutions
- Developing content that serves multiple channels
- Creating stronger connections between content and business goals
- Building authority through expertise, not just volume
LLM Optimization: A New Challenge
Large Language Models are changing how we optimize content. Like early SEO practices, brand mentions on authority sites matter more than ever. But LLMs present new challenges:
- They don't distinguish between different types of citations
- Authority signals work differently than in traditional search
- Brand consistency matters more than link quantity
- Content needs to serve both human readers and AI systems
Organizational Shifts
Forward-thinking companies are moving SEO teams to product development instead of marketing. This structural change:
- Makes SEO part of product creation from day one
- Improves natural ranking potential
- Creates better user experiences
- Aligns SEO goals with product success
The shift reflects SEO's evolution from a marketing tactic to a core business function. SEO professionals now influence product development, ensuring search optimization is built into products rather than added later.
Measuring Success Differently
Traditional channel-based metrics are becoming obsolete. Modern companies need new frameworks that:
- Track message success across all channels
- Focus on revenue impact over traffic
- Measure engagement quality
- Consider brand growth indicators
SEO teams need dedicated testing budgets, just like paid search teams have had for years. As one marketing leader noted, "If you know your audience well, you know they'll love something even if it's new."
Making Innovation Work
Successful innovation in SEO requires:
- Deep audience research to reduce risk
- Clear connection to business goals
- Cross-channel measurement
- Dedicated testing resources
- Leadership buy-in for new approaches
Companies often hesitate to innovate in SEO because they can't predict exact returns. But waiting for perfect forecasts leads to inaction. The key is balanced risk-taking backed by solid audience understanding.
Action Plan for 2025
To succeed in the new search environment:
Immediate Actions
- Audit existing content for consolidation opportunities
- Develop cross-channel measurement frameworks
- Begin shifting SEO closer to product teams
Strategic Changes
- Create dedicated testing budgets
- Invest in deeper audience research
- Start with messages before choosing channels
Long-term Initiatives
- Build genuine authority in your space
- Create stronger product-content connections
- Develop multi-channel content strategies
The Bottom Line
Companies that win in 2025 will focus on quality over quantity and real business results over traffic numbers. They'll:
- Produce less but better content
- Integrate SEO with product development
- Measure success across channels
- Invest in audience understanding
- Take calculated risks on innovation
The fundamental goal remains unchanged: connect the right people with the right solutions when they need them. But the path to success now requires deeper investment in quality, understanding, and integration across the business.
Remember LeRoy's key insight: if maintaining your traffic levels in 2025 means you're actually growing your real impact. Focus on building value for your audience, and the metrics that matter will follow.
